Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

cipherbrief

Welcome! Log in to stay connected and make the most of your experience.

Input clean

A Successful Space Race Needs More than “Competitive Supremacy”

The final frontier must be mutually beneficial for both US and Allies to be sustainable

While the demand for digital sovereignty continues to accelerate, driven by geopolitics and strategic necessity, recent announcements about space supremacy, the unqualified success of Artemis and massive industry growth have created what can only be described as excitement beyond any recent experience. The vision, potential addressable markets, technological innovation, and the challenges and opportunities ahead are significant and possibly already past the point of regulation.


But it does raise a profound question: how can the very nature of space as a highly contested domain align with the sovereign interests of both the US and its Allies? And why must these interests be protected for the benefit of the Alliance?

Given the existential nature of the outcomes, we cannot leave the question purely to fate.

At a time that the White House is asking allies to be more self-sufficient simultaneous with the State Department reportedly being instructed to discourage allied programs for technological sovereignty, fate seems to be outpacing strategic necessity.

How Large is this Space Opportunity?

In a recent report by Goldman Sachs titled The Second Space Age, they poignantly identified that the First Space Age was dictated by “Governments at the frontier.”

This second age is being led by industry with Government more of a copilot with total addressable market projections exceeding US$1.8 trillion across a diverse range of objectives, tools, infrastructure and industries according to the World Economic Forum. Three key commercial thematics have been proposed as shaping this nascent market: the shift to recurring-service revenue models; commercial operators moving faster than government agencies through lower costs and software-driven development; and sovereignty creating sustained demand for independent space capabilities. Following on from my recent research and policy whitepapers on digital and AI sovereignty, it is this third dynamic that will be the long-term structural driver — but what does it actually mean for space?

The foundational principle of modern space law is clear: no nation can claim sovereignty over outer space. Yet in practice, sovereignty is not absent but simply redefined. The 1967 Outer Space Treaty established space as "the province of all mankind," written when only a handful of states had access to orbit. Today, more than 90 countries possess space capabilities and commercial operators account for the majority of launches. Orbital infrastructure now underpins navigation, finance, climate modelling and national security. The real question is no longer whether sovereignty exists in space but who is not-so-quietly exercising it.

In 1962, President Kennedy entranced the world with his inclusive vision: “We set sail on this new sea because there is new knowledge to be gained, and new rights to be won, and they must be won and used for the progress of all people.”

Just last week, President Trump proclaimed a compelling vision in The American Declaration of Freedom in Space reaffirming “that that our solar system and all of outer space beyond Earth are the province of all humans, and that our Nation will lead the way in the exploration, development, use, and settlement of these new frontiers - forging an interplanetary civilization founded on the enduring and inalienable rights of freedom and individual liberty.”

Vision and Leadership indeed!

For that enduring freedom and inclusivity to come true, 5 significant structural challenges must be collectively addressed.

1. The Legal Paradox of Ownership Without Sovereignty

The Outer Space Treaty prohibits territorial sovereignty while simultaneously granting states jurisdiction over objects they launch effectively creating functional sovereignty over satellites and infrastructure. The result: states own jurisdiction over registered spacecraft; private companies control physical infrastructure including mega-constellations; and no actor owns the domain itself. Control is exercised indirectly through licensing, regulatory oversight and operational dominance rather than territorial claims. It is a governance model built for a different era, already straining under the weight of the commercial space age.

2. The Rise of Corporate Sovereignty

The shift from state-led exploration to commercial dominance is the most significant structural change in the space economy. Private companies now own and operate the majority of satellites, launches, and data and intelligence pipelines. Futurist Peter Diamandis has described SpaceX as a "bet on humanity" with an inbuilt moat across orbital transport, infrastructure, compute and AI. For all nations (including US allies), the implication is stark: concentration of space infrastructure risks replicating terrestrial inequalities at orbital scale. Early movers are not just building rockets. They are shaping who controls access to the systems that will define the next century of economic and geopolitical power.

3. Data Sovereignty - Who Owns Information from Orbit?

Satellites collect vast quantities of information forming the backbone of the digital economy. Yet ownership of this data remains deeply ambiguous. It may be controlled by the collecting company, subject to the launching state's jurisdiction, or relate to territories and individuals who have no control over its capture. Existing frameworks, including UN remote sensing principles, were designed for state actors and offer limited guidance on commercial data ownership. In practice, access to space-derived intelligence is determined not by governance frameworks but by economic power and technological capability thereby raising fundamental concerns about equity, privacy and global transparency.

4. Regulation and Enforcement remain the Weakest Links

Space governance today is neither centralised nor uniform. At best it is a layered system of international treaties, national laws and bilateral agreements that was designed for a small number of state actors. It lacks detailed provisions for mega-constellations, space mining and cyber threats. Regulatory disparities across nations allow companies to exploit governance gaps and operate under differing standards. More critically, there is no central authority with the power to enforce rules globally. The physical characteristics of space (scale, remoteness and technical complexity) make real-time oversight inherently difficult. Enforcement will rely on voluntary compliance, diplomacy and market incentives. Similar to global AI governance discussions, that is not a framework fit for a $1.8 trillion economy.

Additionally, the Department of War recently confirmed for the first time it has deployed “on-orbit space control weapons” but without any clarity of when, what type or capability. US allies were not surprised by the announcement and there is a growing (but uneasy) acceptance of militarily contested space domain. While Article IV of the Space Treaty prohibits weapons of mass destruction, it does not prohibit conventional weapons in orbit or ground-to-space defense systems.

5. Who Captures the Value?

Without clear governance, the distribution of value from the space economy risks becoming dangerously concentrated. Early movers secure dominant positions in infrastructure and data markets; states with advanced capabilities shape regulatory norms; smaller and emerging nations risk exclusion from high-value segments entirely. US President Donald Trump has been explicit via Executive Order that the US must ensure "space superiority" across exploration, security and commercial outcomes including as a critical warfighting domain. The geopolitical stakes could not be clearer. Economic sovereignty is replacing territorial sovereignty, and the rules are still being written.

What is absolutely clear is that the anticipation of space becoming a highly contested zone from defence, economic and national security perspectives is NOW a reality. As my former colleague Kelly Bissell recently summarized in this journal: “The result is a domain that is simultaneously more commercial, more crowded, and more contested than at any point in human history and only getting started. Our institutions were built for none of this. It is time to fix that”

The Clarion Call for Expanded Allied Cooperation

Western alliances, from FVEYs to NATO, reinforce the foundational proposition of working together as equals, and anything less will have diminished appeal, acceptance and success in a rapidly evolving geopolitical climate.

Although US space domain investment and capability significantly outweighs its allies individually and collectively, the alliance force-multiplier value proposition of global diversification of innovation, risk, investment, ISR and common values remain just as relevant today as the Apollo Missions in the 1960s – from Britains role in designing the Apollo fuel cell to Australia’s critical role providing continuous tracking and relay services for live broadcasting of the moon landing. Its worth noting that the Australian agency, the CSIRO, that provided those services based on a continuous partnership with NASA since 1960, later greatly benefitted the alliance by also creating the foundation technology underpinning WiFi.

This allied value proposition has been strongly reinforced from the Presidential proclamation through to bilateral space cooperation agreements and the Combined Space Operations strengthening international partnerships. The ambition has been clearly enunciated however the proof will be via increased engagement and integration.

At a minimum, this increased engagement must include:

· Clear definition of the ambition and roles of the US and allies

· Overhaul regulations and the Space Treaty to account for modern reality

· Transform the frameworks and capability for allied intelligence, surveillance & reconnaissance

· Create common allied objectives for delivering the Presidents vision of freedom and liberty for all

The Space Domain Will Redefine Sovereignty Itself & Collective Value of the Western Alliance

Space was once imagined as a realm beyond politics. In reality, it has already become the new frontier of geopolitical and economic competition, not defined by borders but by control over infrastructure, data and access. The challenge for the US and global leaders is not simply to regulate space, but to collaboratively reimagine sovereignty itself: from territorial control to functional influence; from national ownership to multi-stakeholder governance; from fragmented regulation to coordinated global frameworks.

Without decisive action, the principle that space belongs to all humanity risks becoming only symbolic while real power consolidates in the hands of those who can build, launch and control the systems that define it which further diminish an alliance structure already under significant pressure.

Will the Space Age be governed by multinational collaboration with genuine respect for sovereignty? Or will the "might is right" doctrine of centuries past simply be applied to this new and greatest frontier?

Irrespective, the era of ASTROPOLITICS is here. Get ready for blast off.

The Cipher Brief is committed to publishing a range of perspectives on national security issues submitted by deeply experienced national security professionals. Opinions expressed are those of the author and do not represent the views or opinions of The Cipher Brief.

Have a perspective to share based on your experience in the national security field? Send it to Editor@thecipherbrief.com for publication consideration.

Read more expert-driven national security insights, perspective and analysis in The Cipher Brief

Make us preferred on Google

Related Articles

TURKEY-NATO-SUMMIT-DIPLOMACY

What's at Stake as NATO Meets in Ankara

As NATO leaders gather in Ankara this week, the alliance faces a myriad of security challenges unlike anything it has confronted in decades.With [...] More

The Space Age Needs New Rules

Space is no longer a place we visit to plant flags. It is where the global economy and national security now live — and our rulebook is nearly sixty [...] More

Sweden and Denmark are in a Position of Power Over Russia

Two straits, six thousand kilometers apart, are defining the global balance of power in 2026. The first, Hormuz, is closed by force and heavily [...] More

Trump, Iran, and the Stress Test of Western Alliances

The war with Iran has grown beyond just a regional war; it is also a preliminary test of the cohesion of Western alliances under President Donald [...] More

Iran War Scorecard Looks Bad for America’s Strategic Interests

While the war has yet to conclude, we have enough information to create a preliminary net assessment of its effects on U.S. security and prosperity. [...] More

Iran Exposed a New Reality for U.S. Air Power

For thirty years, American wars have contained a quiet assumption: that the skies were uncontested. From Grenada and Panama, through Desert Storm, [...] More

{{}}