The Long Arm of China’s Security Services
SUBSCRIBER+ EXCLUSIVE REPORTING — When Chinese President Xi Jinping came to San Francisco last November to meet with President Joe Biden, Chinese pro-democracy activists in […] More
Bottom Line Up Front
As the protests in Hong Kong continue to evolve from outrage over an extradition bill with mainland China to a broader critique of Beijing’s authoritarian rule, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) is assuming a hardline posture approach with all entities, including private sector companies, that are critical of China. Beijing has consistently pressured companies over issues such as its insistence that Taiwan is not a sovereign country but rather a renegade Chinese province, or any support expressed for the Dali Lama of Tibet. But the recent protests in Hong Kong have seen an increase in Chinese pressure on international corporations. Beijing is hyper-sensitive to public criticism and does not hesitate to use its economic power for leverage in silencing companies, universities, and governments. An example is the muted discussion about the egregious human rights abuses of ethnic Uighurs, a mostly Muslim minority group, in Xinjiang Province. Reports indicate that more than one million Uighurs have been arbitrarily detained under a years-long campaign by Beijing to erase any culture or religion that might compete with loyalty to the state. While some governments have spoken out, most have refrained from commenting, largely for fear of jeopardizing Chinese loans or investments in infrastructure in their respective countries.
In early October, Daryl Morey, the general manager of the National Basketball Association’s (NBA) Houston Rockets tweeted support for the protesters in Hong Kong. This single tweet led to an immediate Chinese backlash. Within days, China, which has substantial financial ties with the NBA, suspended investments and sponsorships while canceling scheduled games on television. The NBA issued a fulsome apology and several high-profile players expressed their ‘love’ for China. Companies like Versace, Apple, and Delta have all run afoul of Chinese sensitivities—over t-shirts saying Hong Kong is a country or airline maps listing Taiwan as a country and not part of China—and all have made public apologies to Beijing and made the requested changes or deletions.
Some companies have decided that the capricious nature of the ‘rule of law’ in China makes investments in one of the world’s largest economies too risky, since Beijing can simply end partnerships or rescind investments at any time. Others have decided that Chinese demands to censor their products are anathema to their company’s business ethics. Google stopped its operations in China after growing frustrated with Beijing’s constant censoring of its search engine. But most companies have decided that the financial gain of operating in or with China outweighs any ethical or moral concerns over censorship and thus continue to work with the authoritarian government.
The ongoing Hong Kong protests are the most significant challenge to the unquestioned rule by China’s Communist Party since the 1989 student pro-democracy protests in Tiananmen Square. China has not yet brought the full weight of its military to crush the protests and the overall movement of dissent in Hong Kong, as it did in Tiananmen Square three decades ago. But if protests continue, the Chinese government could very well unleash its security forces in a more heavy-handed manner. If Beijing uses its military to stifle the protest movement, it will likely face substantial international condemnation but many governments and corporations won’t go beyond words as they consider Hong Kong an ‘internal matter’ for China to handle and use sovereignty as an excuse to continue business and financial relationships at all costs.
Related Articles
SUBSCRIBER+ EXCLUSIVE REPORTING — When Chinese President Xi Jinping came to San Francisco last November to meet with President Joe Biden, Chinese pro-democracy activists in […] More
SUBSCRIBER+EXCLUSIVE EXPERT PERSPECTIVE — More than two years after its withdrawal from Afghanistan, the U.S. still does not have a clear way forward in the […] More
SUBSCRIBER+ EXCLUSIVE REPORTING — Ukrainians greeted Saturday’s long-awaited House passage of $60.8 billion in aid with justifiable jubilation. For months, their soldiers, civilians, and political […] More
SUBSCRIBER+ EXCLUSIVE REPORTING — A race for control of space is underway, and just as on earth, the U.S. and China are the top competitors. […] More
SUBSCRIBER+ EXCLUSIVE REPORTING — For nearly a week, the Middle East and much of the world were on a knife’s edge, waiting for a promised […] More
BOTTOM LINE UP FRONT – Less than one week after Iran’s attack against Israel, Israel struck Iran early on Friday, hitting a military air base […] More
Search