Geopolitics Eclipses International law at the UN

By Catherine Lotrionte

Dr. Catherine Lotrionte is the Director of the Cyber Project in the School of Foreign Service at Georgetown University, where she teaches and writes on international and national security law, international affairs and technology.  She has previously served as Counsel to the President's Foreign Intelligence Advisory Board at the White House, legal counsel for the Joint Inquiry Committee of the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, and Assistant General Counsel at the CIA. 

No consensus report resulted from the yearlong negotiations of the 5th United Nations Group of Governmental Experts (GGE) on the Developments in the Field of Information and Communications Technologies (ICTs). As the meeting drew to a close in June, the 25 government officials ended their work with a disappointing acknowledgement that final attempts to report on areas of agreement related to norms and confidence building measures had ultimately failed, leaving the future of the GGE unclear. There was agreement, however, on the reason for the breakdown: disagreement over fundamental aspects of international legal rules. However disappointing the outcome may be for establishing norms for cyberspace, the result says more about the UN political process of seeking agreement on the nuances of international rules and their interpretations then it does about the potential to establish non-binding norms for cyberspace.

So what do the divisions over the interpretation of international law, as illustrated within the GGE discussions, mean for the future development of international law in the context of cyber operations?

“The Cipher Brief has become the most popular outlet for former intelligence officers; no media outlet is even a close second to The Cipher Brief in terms of the number of articles published by formers.” —Sept. 2018, Studies in Intelligence, Vol. 62

Access all of The Cipher Brief’s national security-focused expert insight by becoming a Cipher Brief Subscriber+ Member.

Subscriber+


Related Articles

Search

Close